Redirecting

Saturday, February 28, 2009

The Oracle of Omaha

Warren Buffett's 2008 letter to Berkshire Hathaway shareholders is out. I'm going to pull what I found to be the most interesting quotes for you here:

"We’re certain, for example, that the economy will be in shambles throughout 2009 – and, for that matter, probably well beyond – but that conclusion does not tell us whether the stock market will rise or fall." - page 4

"When investing, pessimism is your friend, euphoria the enemy." - page 5

"Additionally, the market value of the bonds and stocks that we continue to hold suffered a significant decline along with the general market. This does not bother Charlie and me. Indeed, we enjoy such price declines if we have funds available to increase our positions. Long ago, Ben Graham taught me that “Price is what you pay; value is what you get.” Whether we’re talking about socks or stocks, I like buying quality merchandise when it is marked down." - page 5

"Our long-avowed goal is to be the “buyer of choice” for businesses – particularly those built and owned by families. The way to achieve this goal is to deserve it. That means we must keep our promises; avoid leveraging up acquired businesses; grant unusual autonomy to our managers; and hold the purchased companies through thick and thin (though we prefer thick and thicker)" - page 7

"As we view GEICO’s current opportunities, Tony and I feel like two hungry mosquitoes in a nudist camp. Juicy targets are everywhere" - page 8

"Reinsurance is a business of long-term promises, sometimes extending for fifty years or more. This past year has retaught clients a crucial principle: A promise is no better than the person or institution making it. That’s where General Re excels: It is the only reinsurer that is backed by an AAA corporation. Ben Franklin once said, “It’s difficult for an empty sack to stand upright.” That’s no worry for General Re clients." - Page 9

"Why are our borrowers – characteristically people with modest incomes and far-from-great credit scores – performing so well? The answer is elementary, going right back to Lending 101. Our borrowers simply looked at how full-bore mortgage payments would compare with their actual – not hoped-for – income and then decided whether they could live with that commitment. Simply put, they took out a mortgage with the intention of paying it off, whatever the course of home prices. Just as important is what our borrowers did not do. They did not count on making their loan payments by means of refinancing. They did not sign up for “teaser” rates that upon reset were outsized relative to their income. And they did not assume that they could always sell their home at a profit if their mortgage payments became onerous. Jimmy Stewart would have loved these folks." - page 11

"Commentary about the current housing crisis often ignores the crucial fact that most foreclosures do not occur because a house is worth less than its mortgage (so-called “upside-down” loans). Rather, foreclosures take place because borrowers can’t pay the monthly payment that they agreed to pay. Homeowners who have made a meaningful down-payment – derived from savings and not from other borrowing – seldom walk away from a primary residence simply because its value today is less than the mortgage. Instead, they walk when they can’t make the monthly payments." - page 12

"Home ownership is a wonderful thing. My family and I have enjoyed my present home for 50 years, with more to come. But enjoyment and utility should be the primary motives for purchase, not profit or refi possibilities. And the home purchased ought to fit the income of the purchaser. The present housing debacle should teach home buyers, lenders, brokers and government some simple lessons that will ensure stability in the future. Home purchases should involve an honest-to-God down payment of at least 10% and monthly payments that can be comfortably handled by the borrower’s income. That income should be carefully verified.
Putting people into homes, though a desirable goal, shouldn’t be our country’s primary objective.
Keeping them in their homes should be the ambition." - page 12

"Investors should be skeptical of history-based models. Constructed by a nerdy-sounding priesthood using esoteric terms such as beta, gamma, sigma and the like, these models tend to look impressive. Too often, though, investors forget to examine the assumptions behind the symbols. Our advice: Beware of geeks bearing formulas." - page 15

"I have pledged – to you, the rating agencies and myself – to always run Berkshire with more than ample cash. We never want to count on the kindness of strangers in order to meet
tomorrow’s obligations. When forced to choose, I will not trade even a night’s sleep for the chance of extra profits." - page 16

"Approval, though, is not the goal of investing. In fact, approval is often counter-productive because it sedates the brain and makes it less receptive to new facts or a re-examination of conclusions formed earlier. Beware the investment activity that produces applause; the great moves are usually greeted by yawns" - page 16

"Improved “transparency” – a favorite remedy of politicians, commentators and financial regulators for averting future train wrecks – won’t cure the problems that derivatives pose. I know of no reporting mechanism that would come close to describing and measuring the risks in a huge and complex portfolio of derivatives. Auditors can’t audit these contracts, and regulators can’t regulate them. When I read the pages of “disclosure” in 10-Ks of companies that are entangled with these instruments, all I end up knowing is that I don’t know what is going on in their portfolios (and then I reach for some aspirin)." - page 17

"Derivatives contracts, in contrast, often go unsettled for years, or even decades, with counterparties building up huge claims against each other. “Paper” assets and liabilities – often hard to quantify – become important parts of financial statements though these items will not be validated for many years. Additionally, a frightening web of mutual dependence develops among huge financial institutions. Receivables and payables by the billions become concentrated in the hands of a few large dealers who are apt to be highly-leveraged in other ways as well. Participants seeking to dodge troubles face the same problem as someone seeking to avoid venereal disease: It’s not just whom you sleep with, but also whom they are sleeping with.

Sleeping around, to continue our metaphor, can actually be useful for large derivatives dealers because it assures them government aid if trouble hits. In other words, only companies having problems that can infect the entire neighborhood – I won’t mention names – are certain to become a concern of the state (an outcome, I’m sad to say, that is proper). From this irritating reality comes The First Law of Corporate Survival for ambitious CEOs who pile on leverage and run large and unfathomable derivatives books: Modest incompetence simply won’t do; it’s mindboggling screw-ups that are required." - page 17 & 18

Warren also has an interesting analysis of how he thinks the Black-Scholes options pricing model overstates the risks in the put options he has sold when looking at long term options, on page 20 of the letter.

-KD

Tuesday, February 24, 2009

The Wall Street Journal is Wrong

In poker, there's a saying, "don't tap on the glass." When someone is being an idiot - a fish, you don't educate them - you let them be an idiot and you take their money.

However, when I read something that I know is blatantly false in a paper with as much clout as the Wall Street Journal, it bugs me. WSJ reporter John Jannarone wrote an article on the GLD trust on Sunday that fundamentally misunderstands how the trust works, and since he's not the only one (I read some "GLD IS A SCAM!" articles which posed similar questions), I felt the need to explain it here.

First, let's review his claims:

"ETFs such as SPDR Gold Shares -- ticker GLD -- are a direct bet on bullion prices. The trusts have to buy physical gold to match investment levels. Having doubled the gold in their vaults in a year, the stash is worth $45 billion.That's tiny in the context of big asset classes like stocks. But gold's scarcity keeps the market small. If ETFs continue to grow fast, they could start to create a real squeeze in gold, with its limited supply."


and then in his conclusion:

"If, and when, investors decide the game is up, ETFs will have to liquidate holdings as people sell. Just as they are squeezing the market now, they could flood it when the frenzy ends."


OK - Mr. Jannarone has one thing right that a lot of people fail to understand - GLD is indeed a direct bet on bullion prices - they own gold bullion, not futures or options. You can read all about the details of the GLD Trust here.

However, when an investor goes out and buys GLD, there is no resulting effect causing the trust to "buy physical gold to match investment levels." That's simply not how it works. When you buy shares of GE, the money doesn't go to GE - it goes to whomever sold the shares to you. When you buy shares of SPY, the money doesn't go to the SPY trust in order to buy a basket of S&P 500 stocks. Similarly, when you buy GLD, the money doesn't go to the GLD trust - it goes to the seller of the GLD on the exchange. The trust has nothing to do with it.

Now, you are able to create shares of GLD (in 100,000 share increments) if you go out and buy the corresponding amount of gold bullion. You can take your bullion, deliver it to the trust, and get shares - but the trust doesn't have to go out and buy any bullion. Similarly, if you have 100k shares of GLD, you can give them back to the trust (aka, "Redeem") and they will give you gold bullion in return.

The reason the shares outstanding of the GLD are increasing is because someone is creating GLD shares. Even though GLD frequently trades very close to its net asset value, (you can get the data here) I'd guess that someone has been shorting GLD when it trades rich (above NAV), and buying bullion. This arbitrageur then takes his bullion and delivers it to the trust, and received GLD shares to cover his short.

There has been a lot of talk lately about the USO Oil ETF, and its impact on the oil market. The USO is structured differently from the GLD in that it owns oil FUTURES, which must be rolled each month. The assets of the USO are a huge percentage of the outstanding open interest in oil futures, and thus it ends up costing the trust a great deal each month when they roll their futures position, because everyone in the market knows they are coming and rips their eyes out. GLD, on the other hand, doesn't have to roll anything - they just hold their gold bullion in their vault.

This is neither a recommendation to buy or sell GLD - just an attempt to correct a common misunderstanding out there in the market.

Thus concludes today's lesson.

-KD

Sunday, February 22, 2009

Ridiculuous Snippets of the Week

Ok, it's time for another installment of "Is it Real? Or Is it From The Onion?"

1) Senator Skeptical About Loaning $30Billion to GM:
"Borrowing $30 billion from taxpayers to finance its restructuring could weigh General Motors down too much for the company to be viable, an outspoken senator who voted against aid for automakers said Wednesday...Senator Bob Corker, a Tennessee Republican, said that he did not know whether he would support the larger loan requests that G.M. and Chrysler made Tuesday, but that he had reservations about G.M. owing taxpayers $30 billion, nearly 24 times the amount that the company is worth based on its outstanding stock. Mr. Corker said he was also concerned that G.M., which was negotiating with bondholders to cut much of its debt to them, would continue to ask for more money.


2) Employee Who Likens Self to TV's "House" Fired:
ALPINE, NJ—Walter Salinger, 38, a U.S postal employee who often compared himself to the cantankerous yet brilliant titular character from the Fox medical drama House, was recently fired for insubordinate behavior, coworkers reported Tuesday. "He was either outright rude to customers or avoided them completely," said letter carrier Lyle Davis, whom Salinger often referred to as one of his "team," even though both men hold the same title.


3) Obama Warns Mayors Not to Waste Stimulus Money:
"Invoking his own name-and-shame policy, President Barack Obamawarned the nation's mayors on Friday that he will "call them out" if they waste the money from his massive economic stimulus plan."

So, did you figure it out yet? Sadly, only story 2 is from The Onion. When I read story 1, "Senator Skeptical About Loaning $30Billion to GM" on the NY Times site I thought their site must have been hacked. I read the article, looking for the joke, or the sarcasm, but there was nary a trace of acknowledgement! I mean, come on - Bob Corker is the only senator skeptical about this? That's impossible. I refuse to believe that. To me, this headline was the clear winner in the "Stating the Obvious" category of reporting.

Story 3, "Obama Warns Mayors Not To Waste Stimulus Money," also should have been a joke, but wasn't. If the chief tool the President is employing to make sure that our nation's governors don't waste the hundreds and hundreds of billions of dollars he just appropriated is "name and shame," well then, in the words of my most loyal reader, Bones, "We're doomed. FMyLife."

Supporters of Senator Daniel Inouye's (Hawaii) stimulus item of $198 million for Filipino veterans of WWII have already acknowledged that "they did not expect the payments to do much to stimulate the economy, but that it was a way to bypass opponents who had blocked payments in the past". So is President Obama going to SHAME them? Ridiculing them while Rahm Emanuel, Nancy Pelosi and Barney Frank dance behind him chanting "Oh SNAP! you got SERVED!" ???

I guess we'll have to wait and see.

EDIT: I almost forgot this most absurd story of the week:
"Nigerian Accused in Scheme to Swindle Citibank."

To carry out the elaborate scheme, prosecutors in New York said on Friday, the man, identified as Paul Gabriel Amos, 37, a Nigerian citizen who lived in Singapore, worked with others to create official-looking documents that instructed Citibank to wire the money in two dozen transactions to accounts that Mr. Amos and the others controlled around the world.

I mean - wow. Yes, it's real, and no - I have no idea what can even be said about that. This story is like the ULTIMATE satire, and has to prove that Citibank has not yet hit bottom - they clearly still don't understand risk!


-KD


Thursday, February 19, 2009

The Homeowner Affordability and Stability Plan

Ok, so the Obama Administration released their housing bailout. Check out the details here. The White House also published a good list of FAQ's here. I'll ignore the fact that the title of the plan (which is the title of this post) is pretty bizarre, in that any plan which aims to keep home prices from falling by definition makes them less affordable for those looking to buy homes.

So the plan has a few parts. The first part deals with people who want to refinance into a lower interest rate, but are unable to do so because it's almost impossible to refinance if you owe more than 80% of your home's value. The Plan ups this ratio to 105% - those who owe up to 105% of their homes value will be eligible to refinance into new, lower rate fixed rate mortgages. There are some examples illustrated here.

This is good - allowing people to refinance into a more reasonable interest rate is a fine goal.

The second part of the plan is basically aimed at incentivizing "at risk" borrowers and lenders to avoid foreclosure. In other words, if there are borrowers who are borderline foreclosure candidates, the government is offering to share part of the burden with the lender if the lender aims to restructure the loan so that the borrower has a less burdensome monthly payment. The government set 31% of monthly income as the goal for maximum mortgage payments. Although, according to the example worksheet I linked above, the outstanding principal balance of the loan will not change, the government will subsidize the interest rate to a below market rate to achieve the lower monthly payment.

In addition, the government offers incentives to both the borrower and the lender to remain current on the mortgage - $1k reduction in principal for the borrower for every year (up to 5 years) they remain current, and $1k per year (for 3 years) to the lender for enabling borrowers to remain current! Finally, they offer $500 incentives to mortgage servicers and $1500 incentive to mortgage holders who modify mortgages before they become delinquent. Again, they are disualifying those borrowers who own more than 105% of the value of their home.

Now, this part of the plan is a little dicier. Instead of looking at it as the absolutely absurd idea of both subsidizing and paying people to pay their mortgages, which goes against every value I have, I believe the goal is to reach a better outcome for all parties involved (lender, borrower, other homeowners in the neighborhood) who would do worse if the lender went through with foreclosure (which is expensive for the lender, obviously not good for the borrower, and lowers surrounding home values.)

The final part of the plan is more money dumped into Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac to continue to buy mortgages, as well as an increase in the maximum allowable size of their portfolios. I'll just ignore this part of the plan, since there's no use complaining about how we were supposed to be winding down FNM and FRE's heft, not increasing it - as was stated when the government bailed THEM out.

Now, one reason I'm not outraged as a fiscally conservative free markets American is that I don't think this plan is egregious. Unfortunately, because it's not egregious I don't believe it will be transformational. At best, the plan will allow borderline foreclosure cases to restructure into mortgages they will be able to pay off. At worst, it will delay their foreclosures for a few years. What it won't do, I PRAY, is bail out the morons who have no hope of paying back their debts.

Obama is not an idiot. He knows he cannot and should not bail out everyone. Unfortunately, I think there are a lot more people in the "shouldn't and cannot be bailed out" category than the President estimates, and that this housing plan will be like a finger in the dike (the retaining wall kind, not the lesbian kind).

I have thoroughly enjoyed reading the comments from NY Times readers on the Housing Plan. When there is so much outrage from an audience as supremely liberal as the Times', you know The People are getting mad. The link to the comments is sorted by ones which NY Times readers most approved of. I strongly agree with the sentiment of many of the comments, which basically revolves around the common theme of "Why are we rewarding fiscal irresponsibility?" My two most liberal colleagues continue to argue with me that we need to bail out these at risk homeowners because we cannot allow the housing market to just collapse and face armageddon in our society. I strongly disagree with this notion of homeowners being essentially "too big to fail." Millions of Americans were given a taste of a life they could never afford as a result of a bubble of massive proportions. Now they will need to go back to the life they had before they were given $700k houses on $50k incomes. It can be undone, and there are millions of other families waiting to buy these houses when they are allowed to be priced at normal market prices.

Part of the problem is that my friends don't sympathize with me because they know I'm still well off, even if I'm getting raped on my massive rent each month because I was responsible and didn't buy an apartment at the top of the market. Even though it's unfortunate that my wife and I will probably leave NYC shortly because this cost of living is ridiculous, I still have options.

I explained to these liberal friends that they shouldn't think about me - they should think about my sister and her husband, who are both teachers living (renting) in suburban Boston. How will my sister be able to afford a home if the government acts to inflate home prices artificially (and I dare anyone to explain to me how any sort of government subsidy can be viewed as anything other than artificially keeping home prices higher.) My step-sister also lives (rents) outside of Boston. Her husband drives to Providence before dawn every morning to work a temp job to earn money for the business he is working on developing. How can they ever hope to afford a house if the government is attempting to keep home prices higher - rewarding those who took on mortgages they couldn't afford?

I tried to explain to my bleeding heart liberal friends that by helping one (imprudent) family, the irresponsible borrower family, the government is hurting another (prudent) family - the "saving and waiting for AFFORDABLE housing" family. It's quite clear to me which way that scale should tip.

I leave you first with a NY Times comment from "Jessica in Brooklyn," which I think illustrates my point:
In other news, I am barely making enough to pay my student loans, rent, food, insurance and save for a down payment. To me, mortgage is a privilege. Nobody is helping folks pay their rent, so why should we spend so much money to help those who purchased too much house. I don't want to see families become homeless, but this all very frustrating for someone who is trying to purchase a home the right way. Hey Obama, I didn't get a good return on my law school education. Can you help me out with my bills?
and then with today's outburst from CNBC's Rick Santelli, who is one of the most reasonable and well informed reporters they have. This was immediately dubbed "The Chicago Tea Party."

-KD

Tuesday, February 17, 2009

Remember Back When This Was a Lot of Money?

"GM told the federal government Tuesday that it needed to increase its loan request to $30 billion, $12 billion more than it had initially sought in order to avoid bankruptcy."

And if we're lucky, that will tide them over for a few more months.

I really don't know what else to say about this disaster, except that it makes the extra $2B Chrysler requested look like a bargain. Just to be clear, that's an EXTRA $2B, totaling $9B for Chrysler.

Fortunately, I doubt I'll have to stew over the auto disaster for long, as Obama will unveil his homeowner bailout plan tomorrow afternoon.

I recommend CNBC's special "House of Cards" - about the entire housing and MBS/CDO boom and bust. It highlights the complete lack of responsibility at every step in the mortgage food chain. As I wrote in my Blowjobs and Mortgages post almost a year ago, I take issue with people blaming "Wall Street." Wall Street was guilty of making bad loans - and you can never blame the lender in that situation, as lending money to people who cannot repay it is never a profitable business model. CNBC did a good job reminding the viewer that each of the troubled homeowners they focused on took out mortgages they could not afford, while not absolving mortgage brokers and Wall Street securitizers from their role in picking up a piece of the pie. As one mortgage originator explained it, "What could I do? If I wouldn't lend them the money my share would go to zero and 20 others would lend it to them." (not an exact quote)

I would have liked to see more hard questions asked to the bond rater from Moodys who they focused on. I still think that if anyone other than the borrowers are to blame, it's the ratings agencies. I also didn't realize that Alan Greenspan himself had, back in 2004 I believe, encouraged mortgage issuers to come up with alternatives to the traditional fixed rate mortgages.

As I watched this special with my wife, she was shocked when they started describing negative amortization loans. This is a mortgage where you actually pay LESS than the interest due each month, so that your outstanding balance goes UP over time. "Who is that good for?" She asked me. I had no answer. (In truth, I think the only people NegAm loans are good for are those who can afford to speculate on future home prices and want additional leverage. Unfortunately, they were used almost exclusively for those who could NOT afford the loans if the home prices failed to continue their steep upward trajectory). "These people aren't even renters," she continued, "they're paying LESS than rent essentially," and she was right. That's a key point that I hope won't be glossed over when we structure any homeowner bailout plan - just because you took out a mortgage doesn't mean you were a homeowner and certainly doesn't mean you deserve help.

My big issue is that I have yet to find a borrower I sympathize with. It's not that I hate humanity - I'm a compassionate conservative - a Libertarian - socially liberal, fiscally conservative - call it what you want. But I believe people should be held accountable for their decisions. My father has driven the same car and lived in the same non-renovated house since the early 90's. He didn't cash out his mortgage equity to get a shiny new kitchen and a mortgage he couldn't afford - and he shouldn't have to pay the price for those who did. Similarly, my wife and I twice failed to buy homes, once during a vicious bidding war in 2000 that made no sense to me, and once in 2005 when we couldn't make numbers work because the condo fees were too high. "But you'd be building equity," people would say. "Sure - if home prices go up, which is not something I'm willing to bet on," I'd reply. So now I'm stuck paying rent still as I wait for house prices to come back to normal levels. I read a comment on a Clusterstock article last week that said it perfectly:

"This is amazing...I did not buy a house for years because I didn't think the pricing made any sense. Now the government is going to use my tax dollars against me be trying to re-inflate the market."

Prudent people should not be held liable for the greed and poor decision making of the masses. There is an old saying, "If you owe the bank $10,000 you have a problem. If you owe the bank $1mm, the bank has a problem." I'm all for people trying to renegotiate their mortgages with their banks - that is a BUSINESS decision for the banks - but I'm adamant that the government should not be involved.

anyway... we'll see what the administration comes up with. Then I'll rant some more.

-KD


Wednesday, February 11, 2009

We Want Jobs!!!

I can't escape parallels to the Onion every where I look. That's probably another sign we're still on the precipice of some sort of major fallout.

Today's moment occurred when I went to the gym. As I waited for the elevator, the television in the lobby was showing a CNN story about a steel plant - I think it was in Missouri - which had to shut down because business sucks.

I stood there and watched this story, which focused on the former workers at the steel plant, who were marching around in the street in protest - one guy had a megaphone of course, and was leading the chants:

"What do we want?"
"JOBS!"
"When do we want them?"
"NOW!"
"What kind of jobs?"
"GOOD JOBS!"
"When?"
"NOW!"

I stood there, mouth agape, unable to shake the feeling that this was completely preposterous. Look - EVERYONE is in favor of higher employment. It's not like the steel company fired all the employees and replaced them with robots - THAT may have been something to march about, even though it's inevitable at some point with technological progress and increased efficiency.

But that's not what happened. The steel plant, as a result of the crappy economy, had to shut its doors because they cannot operate profitably. Was the head of the steel plant marching in the street shouting

"What do we want?"
"PEOPLE TO BUY OUR STUFF!"
"When do we want it?"
"NOW!"

No. He wasn't, because that would be senseless. I just feel like marching in the street in order to protest something that is uncontrollable and is not a violation of anyone's rights is so... how do I say... French.

In funnier news, I give you this video from The Onion:



I also had another epiphany today, as I watched the House Financial Services Committee hearings on the use of TARP funds with the heads of the big Wall Street banks.

Maxine Waters from California is completely ignorant (she's not alone in Congress in that regard) and batshit crazy, but more importantly, she is the black lady in the classic "money hole" video! You don't believe me? Come on - go watch the Money Hole video, and then watch Ms. Waters' questioning (embedded below).

It's really worth watching all 7 minutes:



Compare that to the lady who says "My father worked two jobs so he'd have money to throw in the money hole" from this vid:



oy vey.

-KD

Tuesday, February 10, 2009

In THIS Country

I was surprised that none of the financial blogs I read daily had a comment on this story I found on Bloomberg.com tonight: "China Needs U.S. Guarantees for Treasury Bond Holdings."

See, for the unaware, China owns a metric assload of U.S. Treasury bonds - $682 billion according to the article. Basically, China has lent us money to fuel our consumption binge. In exchange, we buy their LCD TV's and everything else they manufacture.

Strangely, shortly after taking control as the secretary of the Treasury, Tim Geithner decided to lob a financial cold war scud missile right at China, when he accused them of manipulating their currency - keeping it artificially weak to give China an advantage in global trade.

The thing with China is this: they own a ton of our debt - this puts both countries in a bind. We need China to continue to fund our debt and consumption based economy. China probably wants to scale back its purchases of U.S. debt, but they have a tough time doing so, because they're already in up to their eyeballs: they can't just walk away now, or they'll screw us AND themselves. Talk about a game of chicken.

This Bloomberg story though, again, reeks of The Onion. After all - our debt is already guaranteed by the U.S. Treasury. Now they want us to REALLY guarantee it? They want HILLARY to guarantee it?

“In talks with Clinton, China will ask for a guarantee that the U.S. will support the dollar’s exchange rate and make sure China’s dollar-denominated assets are safe,” said He in Beijing. “That would be one of the prerequisites for more purchases.”


All I can think of is the quote from Tommy Boy: "Hey, if you want me to take a shit in a box and mark it guaranteed, I will - I've got the time."

The parallels between what we in the U.S. are going through with our "too big to fail " institutions, and the dilemma China has with it's U.S. debt are startling. China can't just walk away, just like we can't just let Citi and BofA blow up. Still, at some point, they may find that they'll have to reach some sort of compromise and cut their exposure to the U.S.

I'm not a poli-sci expert, and I'm not a global trade expert - but this will be a key talking point for the next several years.

Of course, this post wouldn't be complete without a viewing of another classic Chinese-USA conflict - Costello's microprocessors deal with the Chinese from the Departed. Skip ahead to 3:10 in the video.



"I'm concerned about a Chinaman who thinks it's wise to come to a business transaction with automatic weapons. For his own good tell Bruce Lee and the Karate Kids none of us are carrying automatic weapons, because HERE, in THIS COUNTRY, it don't add inches to your dick."

and then, of course, the capper:

"What we generally do, IN THIS COUNTRY, is: one guy brings the items, and the other guy PAYS him. No ticky - no laundry."

Hey - if all it takes to make China happy is to have Hillary take a shit in a box and put a guarantee on it - so be it. Ship it!

-KD

Real? or from The Onion?

Feb 10th: New York: The New York Lottery is proposing a gamble where the odds aren’t always in its favor -- moving its $1.3 billion prize fund into investments such as stocks, corporate bonds, real estate and hedge funds and out of the safety of U.S. Treasuries. If the agency were to double its annual return to 8 percent as it projects, the prize would be $37 million more for state coffers as New York grapples with a record $13 billion budget deficit next year.


I mean come on... that cannot really be from Bloomberg can it? the NY Lottery, after watching the biggest multi-asset-class blowup in multiple generations has decided it wants to take MORE risk? This has to be from The Onion right?

Nope. It's a real story, and yet another sign we haven't seen the bottom yet.

-KD

Thursday, February 05, 2009

What Can You Say?

Thanks to Dealbreaker for bringing me this gem:

Bloomberg: Fannie Mae, the mortgage-finance company under U.S. government control, will loosen rules for homeowners seeking to lower their loan payments by refinancing.

Fannie Mae will drop some credit-score requirements, reduce income-documentation standards and waive the need for appraisals in some cases, according to a notice yesterday to lenders posted on the Washington-based company’s Web site. The changes apply to loans that the company owns or guarantees.

I mean - wow. Deja vu? I already touched on this when GMAC lowered credit standards: it seems the problem may not be so much a lack of capital to be lent by banks, but a lack of qualified borrowers. This FNM statement is especially shocking since it's basically EXACTLY what caused the mortgage bubble in the first place.

Dealbreaker also had another nice analysis of a WSJ article noting that the central bank cannot prop up prices forever.

At some point someone is going to have to break it to the American people and the world that there is no magic pill. It seems apparent that not even the likes of Helicopter Alan or Helicopter Ben possess the needed capital- even with the printing presses running wide open. Rewriting accounting rules to create the appearance of wealth, buying up nuclear waste at above fair value and trying to re-pump the beach ball of mortgage lending is wishful thinking. The sooner the current administration comes to grips with that, and starts resetting the impossibly high expectations they won the election with, the better. Painful? Yes. But less painful than the fall from grace that will accompany any other path.


As I've said many times: it's a matter of time. You cannot grow or wait your way out of a debt bubble.

-KD

Monday, February 02, 2009

A Truth, What We Should Do, and What We Will Do

I haven't ranted much lately about the government's plans to work out the problem the TARP was supposed to resolve: that banks still hold crappy assets which is resulting in them lending less than people would like. We've now come almost full cycle back to the original TARP plan, which was, to buy Troubled Assets (remember, TARP stands for Troubled Asset Relief Program). Of course, the problem is that if/when the government buys these troubled assets, they will, by definition, be overpaying for them.

John Carney over at Clusterstock had a good piece today, attacking the fallacy that many congressmen and senators have been spouting because they don't know better: that "We need to get bad assets off the books of the banks."

The problem is not that balance sheets are somehow "clogged" with bad assets. If that were really the problem, everyone would immediately agree to this deal: Clusterstock will take all the bad assets. Every single one. Give us your subprime mortgages, your second liens, your bundles of autoloans and student loans and credit card debt. If the problem is that you need these off your balance sheets, we're here to help.

We'll even sweeten the deal by offering to pay you one penny for the assets. Not a "penny on the dollar." We're bidding one penny in total for every asset at the market prices below the value you are carrying them on your books.

Any takers?

We didn't think so.

As our little offer shows, the problem is not that there are no buyers for these assets or that the assets are clogging balance sheets. The banks don't just want to get rid of the bad assets--they want to get rid of them by exchanging them for far more money than anyone is willing to pay. And there's only one entity around that can force people to pay more than they are willing for something--that's the government.

We've made this point before but it bears repeating. Any proposal to buy bad assets from banks means that the government will give the banks cash for trash. The "bad bank" will have to overpay otherwise the banks won't take the deal.

Part of the solution that's been discussed is the good bank/bad bank plan, which basically results in the government buying up all the crappy assets. The problem with this is that, as Carney alluded to, the government will be overpaying for the assets, because the banks don't want to sell them at the true market value (and don't be deceived - the true market value is low for a reason - not because they are "fire sale prices" as a result of frozen credit markets, which was the party line spewed back in October and November. For one example, see Carney's own comment under his post.)

The Kid Dynamite solution is simpler: take the money we'd use to purchase the bad assets, and instead fund a new bank - or several new banks that can resume normal, unfettered lending. This would have multiple effects: primarily that the velocity of money would be higher - these new, pristine banks would be able to lend more to qualified borrowers, because they wouldn't have any questionable assets to hinder them - and we wouldn't have to overpay for crappy assets to get into this situation. Also, the government could directly set mortgage rates and other consumer loan rates at whatever level they wanted through these new, government sponsored banks. The Fed wouldn't need to continue to try to bluff the market that it's going to buy treasury bonds to keep rates low - they could set the rates directly - almost like a new, clean, Fannie and Freddie. All deposits with the current "bad banks" should be guaranteed - and they should then be allowed to fail and unwound in a controlled manner. Maybe this is more difficult than it sounds, but I am convinced that as long as we protect depositors money (instead of SHAREHOLDER money), the bad banks can be allowed to fail and we can re-develop a healthy, unfettered banking system.

This idea is not groundbreaking - tons of other people suggested it back when the original TARP plan was announced. It should now be clear that we can't keep dumping money into insolvent banks and yelling at them "LEND DAMNIT!! WHY WON'T YOU LEND!" If you want to know why they can't lend, read Mish's piece on how fucked Wells Fargo is...

Now, this won't happen. What will likely happen is that the government will announce some sort of massive guarantee program, like what they've already done with Citi, AIG, and BAC. They will tell us that these guarantees will only apply if the crappy assets default, and that the crappy assets will be fine with time. The truth is that this will simply delay our day of reckoning for a little while - because the crappy assets will NOT be fine. As I've said before, you can't grow or wait your wait out of a leverage bubble. It's a matter of time.

-KD

Best Super Bowl Ad

What a game...

This was my favorite ad:


-KD

Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Is it real? or is it from The Onion?

Pop quiz: I'm going to give you two actual quotes from recent news stories, and you need to decide which one is from a real business story, and which one is a satire from The Onion.

1) Bank of America Corp, the biggest U.S. bank by deposits, will leave Chairman and Chief Executive Officer Ken Lewis in charge as the company tries to absorb the operations and losses of Merrill Lynch & Co.

“The board today during their regular meeting expressed support for Kenneth Lewis and the Bank of America management team, noting their experience in managing through challenging environments and in assimilating mergers,” said lead independent director Temple Sloan in a statement supplied by the bank.

I mean, come on - that CANNOT be real can it? BAC's board of directors actually thinks it's a good idea to leave Ken "I'll pay you $20 billion for that pile of shit" Lewis in charge? Really? Bad idea jeans!

2) CHICAGO—While a majority of the nation's top retailers have reported a decided slump in 2008, economists studying the declining consumer markets are still unable to determine if discount clothing store T.J. Maxx has been affected by widespread recession.

Financial analysts, observing more than 100 locations nationwide, cited large quantities of off-brand and wildly scattered merchandise as evidence that T.J. Maxx has either been devastated by the economic downturn, or is carrying on as usual in spite of it.

Seems like it could be legit - I mean, TJ Maxx always looks like it's in a complete state of disarray, as if the store has just been ravaged by a tornado.

Correct answers are in the comments.

-KD

Monday, January 26, 2009

Bad Idea Jeans

You remember the classic SNL fake commercial for Bad Idea Jeans right? Well, perusing the free daily newspaper this morning, I came across this gem:

Cops: Drunken worker set fire to WTC elevator - A commodities broker who police say was intoxicated was arrested after he allegedly tried to set fire to a freight elevator he was trapped in. Ryan Brinkerhoff, of Jersey City, got trapped in the elevator at 7 World Trade Center early Saturday and started the fire in an effort to attract attention, police said.

Wow. Bad Idea Jeans. I immediately posed the question to my wife, "How drunk would you have to be for you to think it was a good idea to start a fire in order to attract attention if you were trapped in an elevator?" I'm pretty sure I've never been that drunk. I also love the use of the word "allegedly" in the report, like it wasn't determined if he tried to set fire to the freight elevator or not.

-KD

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

The Prince!

language NSFW.

Quotable

Firstly, I don't think enough has been made about the CBO's report on the valuation of the TARP "investments" so far - so go read that post again.

I read two good quotes today: first, from LongOrShortCapital:
There is no means of avoiding the final collapse of a boom brought about by credit expansion. The alternative is only whether the crisis should come sooner as the result of voluntary abandonment of further credit expansion, or later as final and total catastrophe of the currency system involved. -Ludwig von Mises, Human Action (1949)

the other was on Paul Kedrosky's site:
The British government plans to provide insurance for new asset-backed securities. That is like helping a junkie to detox by guaranteeing drug supplies until the local dealer resumes normal service.
-- Source: John Kay (in FT)

-KD

Friday, January 16, 2009

Heroes and Goats

First off, major props to US Airways pilot Capt. Chesley B. Sullenberger III, who pulled off the 6 sigma move of ditching his aircraft in the Hudson yesterday with no casualties. I believe this is the first time a wide body commercial aircraft has executed a water landing with no casualties. It was about 12 degrees in NYC yesterday, with 40 degree water temperatures, by the way. Hats off to you Captain Sullenberger.

Unfortunately, there are other topics to address, and while I briefly contemplated putting them in a separate post, that would have just bumped Capt. Sully down the page, so I'll hit them here.

1) This BofA bailout is absurd. I mean, truly ridiculous. Remember how crazy the original idea of buying troubled assets from the financial institutions was? Well, we've taken that idea, and crappified it to the Nth degree: now we, the taxpayers, don't even get any potential upside from backstopping these troubled assets. Instead, we guarantee the banks (Citi, and now BofA) against losses, and they keep the upside. I mean - what more can I say? Way to go Hank Paulson.

2) California will be delaying income tax refunds because, well, they're broke! but don't worry I'm sure things will get better because:

3) We, the taxpayers, have given Chrysler a $1.5B low interest loan so that, get this - they can loan the money out at LOWER interest! As we saw with GMAC, I guess they'll make up for it in volume.

4) I've saved the best for last. Surprisingly, not much was made of this report from the Congressional Budget Office on the status of the TARP results (from the government's investment perspective) so far. Let me give you the key points:

"This is the first of CBO’s statutory reports on the TARP’s transactions. Through December 31, 2008, those transactions totaled $247 billion...CBO estimates that the subsidy cost of those transactions (broadly speaking, the difference between what the Treasury paid for the investments or lent to the firms and the market value of those transactions) amounts to $64 billion."

For those of you who can't do the math, or translate this to layman's terms: They are saying that the government is already down $64B on a $247B investment, or roughly 26%. This is especially shocking since most of the funds weren't even disbursed until mid December. Down 26% in about a month - great work - sounds like a good investment to me!

The report provides fascinating details, like that they expect a loss of $21B on the $40B AIG bailout, and a loss of $3B on the $5B GMAC bailout. They also expect losses of $3B on the other $4B of loans to the other auto companies. That's losses of 75% on funds that were disbursed less than three weeks ago. Please, let's not let anyone use the terms "loan" or "investment" again - these number CLEARLY show that these are BAILOUTS.

At the risk of sounding like Karl Denninger, I'm really starting to feel like we, the people of the United States of America, are being raped by Hank Paulson. And it doesn't feel good.

-KD

Thursday, January 15, 2009

Don't Hate the Playa - Hate the Game

In case you're unaware, today's atrocity is that Hank Paulson and his boys allegedly promised Ken Lewis, CEO of Bank of America, more government money a month ago, after Lewis engaged in financial terrorism by threatening to walk away from his horrendous deal to buy Merrill Lynch (which I wrote about a full FOUR months ago!). The government supposedly feared this would roil the markets, and made a secret handshake with Lewis. The details will be released with BAC's earnings next week.

Instead of writing a rambling 5000 word rant on how absolutely insane this latest Bank of America bailout story is, I'm going to give you two links which I think have already covered the point well:

1) Clusterstock:

BAC CEO Ken Lewis decided to buy Merrill Lynch. No one forced him to do it. If it was such a bad decision that it threatened to kill the firm, he should resign in disgrace (or, if he refuses to do so, he should be sacked). It's not as though he didn't have plenty of warning.

If Hank Paulson promised Bank of America more money, meanwhile, both he and BAC should have disclosed this immediately. This is highly material information. It's also NOT a private deal. It's a government deal. The public deserves to know about this instantly.

Taxpayers should be furious at how they and their money are being treated by a government that supposedly exists to represent them. Bank of America did not buy Merrill Lynch for the good of the country: It bought it because Ken Lewis thought, wrongly, that he was getting a deal. Ken Lewis should be held accountable for this. Hank Paulson, meanwhile, should immediately disclose exactly what this secret deal was, when he made it, and why.

2) Barry Ritholtz

So the horrific deal Citibank cut with Treasury was a blueprint, an example for the next foolish investment — and here it is: Bank America, a supposed good bank, that couldn’t wait to get their hands on Merrill Lynch, now a bad bank.

And now that we all see what a terrible decision that was by supposedly sophisticated private sector players, well, then rather than take the hit, BoA has their grubby hands out begging for some taxpayer loot to paper over their idiotic decision-making. First they bought that giant manure pile CountryWide, and now they own another stinking pile of enzyme-free donkey-fazoo, Merrill Lynch.

I say, fuck ‘em. Why do I have to pay for their bad judgment?

Enough already! Fire Ken Lewis, he’s a bum. He’s made several horrific acquisitions, and needs to serve up his head on a platter for his god-awful lack of judgment. Toss out the entire Board of Directors, too, as they all suck. They’ve bankrupted the company, its time they all need to go.

While I certainly agree with both articles, I think Barry is misplacing the blame a little bit. Ken Lewis is just a playa in this scam - Hank Paulson is the one who keeps doling out the dough - can you blame Lewis for asking? The blame lies with Paulson.

And before anyone gets any crazy ideas about how we HAD to bail out BAC because they are too big to fail and if they walked away from MER it would have destroyed the financial system: let me explain one thing: as long as the government guarantees all deposits in bank accounts (which they haven't done yet, but could easily do!) - the financial system would be ok. Failed banks can be easily replaced with new, untainted capital, which would then be available to lend. Contrast this to the current situation, where blood (money) is being pumped into sick patients (banks).

Ken Lewis (CEO of BankAmerica) is one of the worst deal makers in the United States. He bought Countrywide, and then Merrill - each of which he overpaid drastically for, and each of which threatens to poison his firm. Fortunately for him, there is a worse deal maker with even more money watching his back: Hank Paulson. The bad news for America is that Paulson is spending OUR money.

I'll have more when the details of this latest thievery of taxpayer funds are revealed - if my head doesn't explode.

-KD


Saturday, January 10, 2009

If I Could Teach You One Thing

Ok folks - here it is - Kid Dynamite's 2009 Tip of the Year for investing:

Understand the reasoning and arguments of those who hold the other side of your position.

Prices are the result of buyers and sellers expressing their views in the markets. I don't want to get to sidetracked here, but this is why people screaming "the speculators are manipulating prices" - be it by buying oil (so unfair!) or by shorting financial stocks (so unfair!) - is ridiculous. Prices are the end result after everyone in the market has expressed (or had the opportunity to express) his opinion by buying or selling. If "speculators" pump up the price of oil to levels which are completely absurd, then others will come in and sell the oil right back down to a level they feel is fairly priced. If "short sellers" drive the price of a stock down to bargain basement levels, value investors will jump in and buy the stock back up to a price they feel no longer represents compelling value. It should be clear to the reader that any suggestion of banning sellers of financial stocks or buyers of oil is blatantly senseless, and results in falsely manipulated market prices.

In fact, oil prices were so high last summer because the reality of a harsh global recession hadn't yet hit - people were still clinging to arguments like "the average recession lasts x months" instead of waking up to the new paradigm of drastically decreased leverage and slower growth (or recession). Similarly, prices of financial stocks plummeted not because some evil mastermind was shorting the stocks down to zero, but because their balance sheets were unsound, and they were technically bankrupt.

But back to the lesson: I'll throw another simple example out there from the risk-arbitrage world, because I was a risk-arb trader for several years. Dow Chemical has a deal on the table to buy Rohm & Haas (ROH) for $78 in cash (I believe that's the price). This deal was struck back in July of 2007, before the credit markets blew up. Recently, Dow Chemical received notice from Kuwait that the nation was terminating a joint venture with DOW worth roughly $17B, which cast doubt on DOW's ability to finance their acquisition of ROH. Now, I'm not a lawyer, but I'm told that the merger agreement between the two companies is iron clad - it leaves DOW no "outs" to withdraw from the deal - even given the massive deterioration in the global financial markets.

ROH stock now trades around $62. The bull case is that Dow cannot get out of the deal, no matter how much they might want to - and will be legally required to complete the deal at $78 (they even have to pay interest starting next week, so that price goes up). The bear case is that everyone knows ROH would be worth about half that right now if they didn't have the Dow bid, and that Dow will be able to use some sort of other excuse, like insolvency of the combined company to renegotiate a lower bid. You have to understand the logic behind each argument. I don't have a position in ROH, but I made a small wager with a colleague who is a much better risk-arb trader than I am that the deal would NOT get done at the $78 price.

As for the broader markets, I'm intensely bearish. I'm not an economist, but it's clear to me that we're in a new paradigm of debt - one where the lavish spending and growth financed purely by debt for the last 7 years will be reigned in. I am constantly asking myself what the bull case is - how people can think that things will be ok. I think the bull case is based on ridiculous citing of PAST recessions, which are, to me, clearly irrelevant right now. It also hopes that massive government spending will re-ignite the economy and get us out of this mess. The key issue here is that we never allowed the economy to bottom - to stabilize at a natural level from which we could then provide stimulus. On the contrary, we're in a scenario where the economy is falling off a cliff (relatively speaking ) - and the policy makers are trying to "catch a falling knife." I don't think you can stop the inevitable - you can't prevent the pain, you can only delay it.

The bull case also assumes that things will be ok once house prices stabilize. Contrarily, I believe much of the growth of the last several years was a result of people SPENDING their home equity - the term is mortgage equity withdrawal - they treated their homes like an ATM and took their equity out. Now, some of these people have already spent their equity and find themselves with home prices worth less than their current mortgage value. We're supposed to feel sorry for them and bail them out by reducing their mortgage principal owed? They spent that money on a car, a flat screen TV and a vacation already! But lest I get diverted again - back to the point - we won't be able to use our mortgage equity on cars and tv's and vacations in the next 10 years because home values won't be on a 45 degree straight line up!

It seems obvious to me that after you have a drunken feast, you MUST have a hangover where you feel like crap. Well, the last 7 years have been an orgy of debt and spending - and we'll have to take the pain from that era. This pain will be much more than the foreclosures we've seen so far - those were people who never owned their homes in the first place. The next wave will be credit card defaults when revolving debt decreases, and the harsh realization that mortgage equity is not a one way straight line up.

I'd love to see how long the restaurant on my corner selling $8 plates of hummus lasts - or the trendy steak restaurants charging $65 for a fillet mignon. One of the things about NY is that the entire city seemed to be financed by corporate dollars - from restaurants to sports tickets. What will happen now that corporations are reigning in spending? Will they still tolerate $2k dinners for client entertainment? I doubt it... The new Yankee Stadium still had 6 unsold luxury boxes last time I checked - that doesn't bode well for NY corporate spending.

I'm not trying to convince anyone out there to go get short the market. I myself have a tiny short position now - I'm hoping to capitalize on the optimism and potential rally around the beginning of the Obama Administration and new stimulus plan - and establish a short position into the rally. I'm somewhat nervous because I do get the sense that many have this exact idea, and if the rally fails to materialize, the selloff will be swift and will not allow opportunity to establish short positions prior to the destruction.

My point was that regardless of your position, you need to understand what the argument on the other side is. By arguing the opposite, by playing Devil's Advocate with yourself, you can form a better thesis, gain more confidence in your position, or even reverse it all together.

-KD

Wednesday, January 07, 2009

I Learned It By Watching YOU!

Thanks to the Big Show for this all-too-true cartoon:
-KD

Monday, January 05, 2009

Quick, but Good

My two favorite financial bloggers each have questions worth looking at:

1) from Paul Kedrosky: "Is Financial History Bunk?"
I've been arguing for the past year that generally, it IS bunk - it's useless to compare the AVERAGE length of past recessions, because we've never had a situation like this, or even close to this current crisis! This is especially scary when you consider that we're relying on a true academic, Ben Bernanke, to get us out of this mess... Kedrosky also points out that the tiny sample size also renders any comparisons highly suspect.

2) from Barry Ritholtz: "Why don't policymakers respond to rising markets?"
Indeed... and this gets back to yesterday's point which I discussed in the Lewis/Einhorn article about the mistake of trying to form policy to protect falling stock prices.

And oh - if there was any doubt about how completely incompetent the SEC was - the WSJ today reports on how they investigated Bernie Madoff at least EIGHT times, but failed to detect the massive fraud that he was perpetuating. Nice work boys.

-KD

Sunday, January 04, 2009

Sunday Reading

There is some good stuff out there to talk about today. First off, Michael Lewis (of Liar's Poker fame) and David Einhorn (kingpin at Greenlight Capital) co-authored a lengthy piece in today's NY Times which takes another look at the financial crisis. Part one begins a little slowly, looking at how attempted Madoff whistle blower Harry Markopolos's claims could have been ignored by the SEC, and segues to the completely incompetent actions of the ratings agencies (Moody's, S&P) and the bond guarantors (MBIA, Ambac). They also mention the SEC's gross incompetence and backwards logic:

"Created to protect investors from financial predators, the commission has somehow evolved into a mechanism for protecting financial predators with political clout from investors. (The task it has performed most diligently during this crisis has been to question, intimidate and impose rules on short-sellers — the only market players who have a financial incentive to expose fraud and abuse.)"


For those of you who are not aware, Einhorn drew wrath and ire in 2007 when he explained in detail why Lehman Brothers had major problems with their balance sheet, and why he was shorting the stock. As a short seller of Lehman's stock, he was accused of having ulterior incentives to see the stock go lower. Of course, Einhorn didn't cause any of Lehman's problems, and was really just a messenger of how they could be fixed. If he'd been listened to instead of attacked, Lehman might still exist today. Needless to say, Einhorn was correct about Lehman.

In part two of their article, Lewis and Einhorn take issue with the Treasury's disbursement of funds, and put the $306Billion government guarantee of Citigroup's questionable assets in perspective:

"The $306 billion guarantee was an undisguised gift. The Treasury didn’t even bother to explain what the crisis was, just that the action was taken in response to Citigroup’s “declining stock price.” Three hundred billion dollars is still a lot of money. It’s almost 2 percent of gross domestic product, and about what we spend annually on the departments of Agriculture, Education, Energy, Homeland Security, Housing and Urban Development and Transportation combined."

I especially liked their observation, which I have made previously, that the government needs to "Stop making big regulatory decisions with long-term consequences based on their short-term effect on stock prices...The hasty crisis-to-crisis policy decision-making lacks coherence for the obvious reason that it is more or less driven by a desire to please the stock market. The Treasury, the Federal Reserve and the S.E.C. all seem to view propping up stock prices as a critical part of their mission"

Lewis and Einhorn's piece is long, but worth reading.

Clusterstock referred me to a great article from the Wall Street Journal about how to better understand the mortgage crisis. The must read story tells of how an unemployed alcoholic woman managed to take out a $103,000 mortgage on her 576 square foot shack in suburban Arizona. It's an absolutely sick story about the gross negligence at every step in the chain: mortgage broker, home appraiser, lender, borrower - which ends with her shack being sold in foreclosure for $18k to her next door neighbors - who no doubt over payed just to remedy the eyesore that her home had become. Wait until you see the pictures.

I also enjoyed Clusterstock's sarcastic story "Economists Who Blew It Agree: Prosperity Just Around Corner."

Finally, although Karl Denninger is a bit of a zealot, I can't really disagree with his logic, and I think it's worth pointing out that he continues to do a good job of explaining why the government's solutions to this financial crisis cannot possibly work. I'm going to leave it in his boldface type, because I think it's simple, accurate, and worth emphasizing.

"The problem is that there is too much debt in the system; adding more debt to the system simply makes the problem worse at an exponentially increasing rate.

It is impossible to fix a problem that is best explained as "too much" of something by adding more of that same thing.

This is true whether the "too much" is a drunk who wants a bottle of whiskey, a crackhead who wants another hit, or a heroin addict who begs for another shot.

You can't solve any of their problems with more of what ails them any more than you can solve a debt problem with yet more debt."

You can also check out Denninger's predictions for 2009. I only include them because his 2008 predictions were pretty darn good, and I tend to largely agree with him on his 2009 outlook.

until next time,

KD

Tuesday, December 30, 2008

GMAC - They'll Make up for it in VOLUME!

Even if you lived in a cave, you probably heard that GMAC will be receiving some (and by "some" I mean "six billion dollars") money from the government. Of course, this is on top of the $13+ billion that GM was promised already, but I want to talk about the math behind GMAC.

GMAC has to pay the government an 8% dividend on this injection of capital (in the form of preferred equity shares) it received. GMAC is turning around and lending this money to would be car buyers at 0% . Now, you may have heard the old maxim regarding the rule of thumb for bankers: 3-6-3: they borrow money at 3% (ie, take in deposits, and pay 3% interest), they lend money at 6% (ie, a mortgage) and they're on the golf course by 3 o'clock. I'm not a math major - no wait - in fact, I AM a math major, and I can tell you that GMAC's 8-0-6 plan won't work... what it will translate to is: borrow money at 8%, lend it out at 0%, and be bankrupt in 6 months. Anyone want to set an over/under on the total amount of money we (the taxpayers) will dump on GM and GMAC before all is said and done? I'd say it's a toss-up between the GM/GMAC total, and the Miami Dolphins vs Baltimore Ravens total for the AFC wildcard playoff game this weekend, which is 37 1/2 points. In GMAC's case, that's 37.5 Billion.

GMAC's most recent move should put to rest any question as to if this is an "investment" or not: I know of no business that makes money borrowing at 8% and lending at zero percent... I guess they'll make up for it in VOLUME! Perhaps the model would stand a chance if they made money on the cars they sold, which they don't.

Reading the Bloomberg article on the subject today left me with another head-scratcher:

"GMAC will now lend to vehicle buyers with credit scores of 621 or higher, compared with a previous standard of at least 700, according to a company statement. The higher threshold had excluded about 42 percent of U.S. consumers."

The company said it won’t finance “higher-risk transactions,” instead concentrating on prime customers who are more likely to repay using “responsible credit standards.”


Wow. Go back and read that again. The standards GMAC were using before this latest bailout meant they were ONLY (note: SARCASM!) lending to 58% of all U.S. consumers! Holy fuck! That doesn't exactly sound like they were only lending to the Rockefellers and Buffets of the world! You're telling me that 58% of U.S. consumers was too narrow a market? As I've said before, the problem isn't a lack of available money to lend, the problem is a lack of qualified borrowers, given that lenders have re-adopted NORMAL, REASONABLE lending standards. GMAC proved this today, by immediately lowering their lending standards so that they could lend more money.

update: I just read Karl Denninger's post from today, where he basically has the exact same line of thought I enunciated above. Denninger also points out that the median FICO credit score in the U.S. is 723. That means that 1/2 of all Americans have a credit score above 723. Thus, 621 cannot possibly considered "prime" as GMAC claims.

happy f'n new year.

-KD

Thursday, December 25, 2008

Merry X-mas


For Oscar's Hanukkah picture, see this post.
-KD

Thursday, December 18, 2008

Read Up!

Some good stories around today:

CSFB designed an interesting solution to the problem of executive compensation in tough times on Wall Street: they took their "troubled assets" and put them into a fund. Senior employees (directors and managing directors) will be given stakes in the fund as part of their compensation! Thus, if the assets are really worth what people say they are, the execs will make out nicely If they're full of it, they'll eat their worthless paper. I especially like the comment on Barry's blog in the link above suggesting that Congress be compensated the same way: with the gains from the "investments" of the TARP loans!

Paul Kedrosky has a link to some must read stuff on Bernie Madoff. If you read the warning letter that Harry Markopolos sent to the SEC years ago it probably won't make you think any higher of the SEC.

Speaking of the SEC, NakedShorts weighs in on Obama's new SEC head: Mary Schapiro:

Schapiro has troubled these pixels but once, when we reported that in 2003, during a period when she was opining vociferously on hedge fund-related broker-dealer disclosures and the adequacy thereof, her valiant sleuths swept through the offices of Bayou Securities LLC in Scamford, Conn.

There, they found $8500 worth of allowing “two individuals to execute transactions...without first obtaining registration as equity traders…” and failing “to update written supervisory procedures reasonably designed to achieve compliance with said regulations…” The missing however many hundreds of millions it was by then quite escaped their attention as, boxes all checked and wrist-taps to come, the sleuths boarded the train back to Boston.

For the uninitiated, Bayou was the original hedge fund ponzi scheme - back before Madoff was discovered. Schapiro apparently had her chance to take a look at their books, but came back with doody.

Clusterstock notes the despicable manipulation of the oil market by short sellers. And, in case you're retarded, they are being sarcastic.

I liked the point of this Bloomberg article, which points out that the Fed is making hundreds of billions of dollars of loans based on the AAA ratings of securities which were rated by the same people who've already proven their ratings cannot be relied on.

Finally, via CNNsi HotClicks, I had no idea there was such a thing as trick bowling:



-KD

Tuesday, December 16, 2008

Innate Behavior?

Oscar after playing in the Mulch Pile

My dog Oscar did something funny this weekend. We stopped at the store and bought him a beef chewy - this tendon thing that he can go to town on. He's had treats similar to it, but never this exact treat before. So, my wife and I are in the backyard cleaning up our patio, and there is a hole in the flower bed that Oscar had dug many weeks before - if he wants to rumble with us, he digs a hole because he thinks it'll antagonize us into chasing him around the yard.
Anyway, he's trying to get us to chase him, but we're only half-heartedly playing with him, cause we're trying to clean up. Oscar ditches us, goes inside and gets his new chew treat, and brings it outside. He places it in the hole, and then I see him moving his face back and forth across the dirt.
I got my wife's attention, and mouthed "what's he doing?" He was burying the bone, using his nose as a shovel! Oscar is a talented digger with his paws, but he elected to replace the dirt with his nose. It was incredible, because 1) I'm certain he hasn't seen another dog do this, and 2) he's not a hound/hunting/digging dog - he's a Brussels Griffon, which is a toy breed, and thus I wouldn't expect him to have any innate "bone burying" tendencies.
For some reason, we were very proud of the guy for showing the desire and ingenuity to bury his bone, and he was obviously insanely cute when he was done, face covered with mud. We were trying to figure out if a) he really liked the treat and wanted to save it or b) hated it and wanted to get rid of it so we would get him something else! I'm leaning toward a).

-KD




Monday, December 15, 2008

Back to Madoff

I want to re-address the Bernie Madoff story for a second here, because something is bothering me. Now, on the one hand, I want to chide the investors in the fund for being greedy and blind: refusing to ask questions about how the fund was making money as long as the money was coming in. HOWEVER, Dealbook, today, published some trading statements that Madoff customers received. Looking at these statements, I can't think of any way that a customer could look at them and have any reason to conclude that the business was anything other than legit.
Said differently, I had a 401k account at Scudder in which I owned a variety of mutual funds. Every quarter, they sent me an accounting statement which shows the change in value of the funds. Obviously, I assumed that my money was actually being invested in these funds. I also assumed that the funds were honestly reporting their positions and trading. I have no reason to assume fraud anywhere in the chain - but Scudder could be completely fabricating my statements, just like Madoff did... I think this is highly unlikely, and thus I'm back to sympathizing with Madoff's investors instead of blaming them for being blind and greedy.
So that takes care of the individual investors, but there was also a massive class of institutional investors (managing money for individuals) in Madoff's fund. Do they have a higher fiduciary responsibility than individuals, and the obligation to know exactly what they are investing their clients' money in? Yeah - I think they do, and I think they are to blame big time. Does the argument "hey, how could Nomura know there was fraud - they were receiving the same phony statements" hold water? I don't know... I want to say "no," but I'm not sure I'm being consistent here...
Anyone have a thought on this?
-KD

Champ

After taking down the third qualifying match last week to force a playoff for the final seat in the Pokerlistings Run Good Challenge 2 Finals, I ran good again this week to bring home the bacon and capture the title, the money, the glory, the trophy, the championship bracelet, and the commemorative watch (note: only the money actually happened...)
Spaceman, Pauly and I had to have a playoff for the final two seats, which we did on Tuesday at midnight. After dispatching Pauly, Spaceman and I both had our finals seats.
In the finals I won the first hand against the PokerShrink, who thinks I'm a maniac, when I three bet him from the button with AhKh and extracted some more value vs his AJ when an ace flopped. I played pretty aggressively, picked up a few hands, avoided some trouble spots, and stuck a fork in Benjo when he trapped me in a pot but left me with plenty of outs. I'd been raising frequently, and with 25-50 blinds I made it 150 to go from middle position with 33, and Michele Lewis called. Benjo on the button made it 550 to go, and I elected to call and see what happened. Michele called as well, and we saw a flop of A-9-4 with two clubs. I checked, as did Michele, and Benjo offered us a free card. The turn was the 5c, giving me a gutshot wheel draw and a three high flush draw, which was obviously the nuts. I bet out half the pot, Michele thought before folding, and Benjo shoved, which was less than a min-raise. I called getting over 5-1, and Benjo's A-J was punked on the river when an offsuit deuce fell.
When will these kids learn to stop taking AJ up against the Kid! DYKWTFIA?!?!?! Anyway, I owed Benjo that for the beat he put on me in the second tourney of this series, when his QQ spiked a river Q against my AA after I'd trapped him. I pointed out that my suckout was about 5% as sick as his suckout, but Spaceman claimed it's more like 8% as sick.
The field was eventually whittled down to myself, Luckbox, Amy Calistri, Pokerlistings host Matt Showell, and Defending Run Good Challenge Champion, Change 100. Amy wielded her short stack with Juanda-esque efficiency: fearlessly blinding herself down almost to the felt before doubling up - a strategy she repeated at least three times before we were finally able to send her to the rail. "Lucky" Matt Showell was on the ropes when I got him to call off his chips with A-2 vs my A-9 on an ace high board, but he was saved when the board paired on the river to earn him a chop. Soon Matt's luck ran out, leaving Luckbox, Change100 and me to fight it out for the glory.
Change100 was unable to pull off the greatest poker back to back since Chan won his second WSOP bracelet, and instead settled for second place against me, after eliminating Luckbox in third place.
Thanks again to Pokerlistings.com for sponsoring this generous freeroll series.
-KD